Crypto.com Logo
Stocks

Common 401(k) rollover mistakes and how to avoid them

Introduction

Moving your old 401(k) the wrong way can create an unexpected tax bill. Read on to learn more about the most common 401(k) rollover mistakes, from withholding traps to missed deadlines, so you can avoid them and keep your savings working for the long term.

author image
Anzél Killian10 minutes
common 401k rollover mistakes

What’s a 401(k) rollover?

A 401(k) rollover involves receiving moving cash or other assets from an old workplace retirement plan and contributing all or part of it to another eligible plan or Individual Retirement Account (IRA). This has to be done within 60 days of receiving the distribution. The money can be paid to you first, in which case you also have 60 days to deposit it.

Why move the money at all? People often want to consolidate accounts, but there could be other benefits to moving your 401(k). None of those reasons makes a rollover automatically the right call – you should compare all the features of the new plan before you decide.

A properly completed rollover transaction isn’t taxable at the time of transfer, although it remains reportable on Form 1099-R and your federal tax return.

You have four choices when it comes to your old employer 401(k):

  1. Leave the money in your former employer’s plan, if the plan allows it. This can preserve the account’s current tax treatment and investments, but you remain subject to that plan’s fees, rules and available investment choices. Small balances may also be handled automatically under applicable plan and rollover rules.
  2. Move the money to a new employer’s plan, if that plan accepts incoming rollovers. This can bring retirement savings together in one workplace plan, although the new plan may have different fees, investment options and transfer requirements.
  3. Roll the money into an Individual Retirement Account with an eligible IRA provider. This may offer more flexibility and investment choice, but fees, services and protections can differ from those of an employer-sponsored plan.
  4. Take a cash distribution. This gives you immediate access to the funds, but eligible rollover distributions paid to you are generally subject to 20% federal withholding. A 10% additional tax may also apply if you’re under age 59½ and no exception is available.

Find out more about what to do with an old 401(k)



Direct vs. indirect 401(k) rollover: What’s the difference?

A direct 401(k) rollover moves funds directly from one eligible retirement plan or IRA to another. The money isn’t paid to you, so mandatory 20% federal withholding doesn’t apply. It also avoids the 60-day rollover deadline that applies when funds are paid to you. 

An indirect 401(k) rollover involves the distribution being paid to you first. In that case, the payer generally must withhold 20% of the taxable amount for federal income tax, even if you plan to redeposit the money into another retirement account. The withheld amount may later be credited against your tax liability, but it can still create a cash-flow issue.

Learn about the difference between a 401(k) rollover vs. transfer

Administrative errors can still happen, but a direct rollover removes two common sources of problems – the 20% withholding and the 60-day deadline. 

Here's a side-by-side look of a direct vs. indirect rollover:


Direct rollover

Indirect rollover

How funds move

Institution to institution; not payable to you

Distribution paid to you

Mandatory 20% federal withholding

Doesn’t apply

Applies to the taxable amount

60-day deadline risk

Avoided

Applies to the participant

Cash you may need to add

None

The 20% withheld, to roll over the full amount


The top 401(k) rollover mistakes to watch out for

1. Failing to use a direct transfer

Choosing an indirect distribution creates an immediate cash shortfall because of the 20% tax withholding rule. For example, on a $50,000 balance, an indirect distribution would send you a check for roughly $40,000, while $10,000 goes to the IRS. 

To complete a full rollover within the 60-day window, you'd have to make up that $10,000 from your own pocket and deposit the entire $50,000 into the new account before the deadline passes. If you don't, the shortfall is treated as a distribution.

2. Missing the 60-day rollover deadline

With an indirect rollover, the clock starts ticking the moment you receive the funds. If you miss the 60-day deadline, the taxable amount you didn't roll over is treated as ordinary taxable income for the year received. On top of that, a taxable retirement-plan distribution made before age 59½ may be subject to an additional 10% early-distribution tax.

The IRS can waive the 60-day rollover requirement in appropriate circumstances, but a waiver isn’t automatic simply because a deadline was missed – procedural requirements apply.

For certain reasons, such as a serious illness or an error by the financial institution, you may be able to self-certify that you qualify for a waiver. Other cases need a ruling from the IRS. See the IRS rollover rules for details.


3. Overlooking 401(k) rollover fees and expense ratios

401(k) rollover fees can include investment-product fees, plan-administration expenses, start-up or conversion charges and service provider termination fees. Federal law requires 401(k) plan fees to be ‘reasonable’, but these expenses can still reduce the assets available to compound for retirement over time.

A few points worth checking:

  • Compare the underlying investment costs in your old plan against what you'd pay in a new IRA or 401(k) plan.
  • Watch for one-time administrative or termination charges when you close out.
  • Remember that fees vary by custodian, so check the applicable plan or account disclosures for exact amounts.

4. Forfeiting unvested employer matching contributions

The full balance shown in your 401(k) may not all be yours to keep. Your own contributions, plus any earnings on them, are always 100% vested. Employer contributions, including matching contributions, may vest over time based on your plan’s rules.

If you leave before those contributions are fully vested, you may lose the unvested portion. Check your plan documents or benefit statement before starting a rollover so you know how much of the balance can actually move.

Your next read: When's the best time to roll over a 401(k)?



Advanced tax pitfalls in 401(k) rollovers

This content is for informational purposes only and isn’t tax advice. Crypto.com doesn’t provide tax advice. Tax rules can vary based on your circumstances, so consider consulting a qualified tax professional about your specific situation. 

1. Losing the Net Unrealized Appreciation (NUA) tax advantage

If your 401(k) holds shares of your employer’s stock, special tax rules may apply when those shares are distributed from the plan. This is known as Net Unrealized Appreciation (NUA) treatment.

Rolling employer stock into an IRA can affect whether NUA tax treatment is available. The rules are complex and depend on how the stock is distributed, so consider speaking with a qualified tax professional before moving employer shares out of a 401(k).

To keep the option open, ask your plan whether the shares can be moved to a regular (taxable) brokerage account while the rest of the balance is rolled over.

2. Giving up the Rule of 55 early retirement exemption

The Rule of 55 is an exception to the 10% additional tax that can apply if you leave your job during or after the calendar year you turn 55 and take distributions from that employer’s 401(k). You may still owe regular income tax on the withdrawal.

The exception applies to qualifying workplace retirement plans, not IRAs. If you roll that 401(k) into an IRA, you give up access to the Rule of 55 for those funds. IRA withdrawals before age 59½ may then be subject to the 10% additional tax unless another exception applies.

This can matter if you leave a job between ages 55 and 59½ and expect to use some of your retirement savings before reaching 59½.

3. Triggering the IRS pro-rata rule on Backdoor Roth IRAs

If you use or plan to use a Backdoor Roth IRA strategy, rolling pre-tax 401(k) money into a Traditional IRA can affect the tax calculation on a later Roth conversion.

That’s because the IRS pro-rata rule looks at your combined traditional, SEP and SIMPLE IRA balances at the end of the year of the conversion when determining how much of a Roth conversion is taxable. A larger pre-tax IRA balance can therefore increase the taxable portion of a Backdoor Roth conversion. If this applies to you, rolling the pre-tax money into a new employer's 401(k) instead keeps it out of that calculation.

Read the full guide on tax implications of a 401(k) rollover



Common 401(k) roll-in problems when transferring to a new employer plan

The most common 401(k) roll-in problems start with whether the plan will even accept the money. A new employer's 401(k) plan may have its own terms governing whether it accepts incoming rollovers and which asset types it can receive. 

Timing can also matter if you have a small balance in a former employer’s plan. The plan may be allowed to distribute balances below $7,000 without your consent. If the amount is over $1,000 and you don't choose where it goes, the plan must roll it into an IRA it selects rather than send you a check.

Contact both plans early. Ask the receiving plan whether it accepts roll-ins and what assets it allows. Also confirm with the old plan how your balance will be handled if you don't act.



How to execute a seamless 401(k) rollover to an IRA

If an IRA rollover is the route you choose, a direct transfer keeps the process straightforward:

  1. Verify your vesting and asset details. Confirm what's fully vested and note any employer stock or special holdings.
  2. Choose your IRA type. Decide between a Traditional IRA or Roth IRA based on your own tax situation. Moving pre-tax 401(k) money into a Roth IRA counts as a conversion, so the amount is taxed as income that year.
  3. Request a direct transfer. This keeps funds out of your hands and avoids 20% withholding and the 60-day deadline risk.
  4. Confirm the full deposit. Check that the entire eligible amount landed in the new account.

Crypto.com IRAs let eligible US users hold stocks, ETFs and crypto assets in tax-advantaged retirement accounts, all managed in one app. You can roll over funds from an eligible former-employer 401(k) via a USD transfer.

Eligible transfers and rollovers may also qualify for a cash match of up to 2%, depending on your Level Up tier.* The match is subject to a four-year holding period. Withdrawing or transferring out early may trigger a fee if your balance falls below your deposits plus the match.

* Only eligible contributions, transfers and rollovers may qualify for a Crypto IRA match, paid in US dollars. Match rates vary by funding method and Level Up tier. Rewards are subject to a four-year holding period and program terms. Rewards aren’t guaranteed and may change.

Please note: On the platform, securities are handled through the broker-dealer entity, Foris Capital US LLC, while digital assets are held via the crypto affiliate. So, equities and digital assets aren’t held in the same account, even though both are accessible in the Crypto.com App.

Stocks, Recurring Buys and Whale Baskets are features only available in the IRA provided by Foris Capital US, LLC, not by Foris DAX Trust Company, LLC. Crypto Recurring Buys are features only available in the IRA provided by Foris DAX Trust Company, LLC.

Cryptocurrency carries risk, including possible loss of principal. Holding crypto in an IRA doesn't reduce its market risk.

Get started with a Crypto.com Stocks IRA



FAQs about 401(k) rollover mistakes

What are the most common 401(k) rollover mistakes?

Common 401(k) rollover mistakes include using an indirect rollover without accounting for mandatory 20% withholding, missing the 60-day rollover deadline, overlooking fees and failing to check vesting or special tax rules before moving the account.

What happens if I miss the 60-day rollover deadline?

If an indirect rollover isn’t completed within 60 days, the amount not rolled over is treated as taxable income for that year. If you’re under age 59½, an additional 10% early-distribution tax may also apply unless an exception is available. The IRS may waive the deadline in certain circumstances, but relief isn’t automatic.

How does the 20% withholding rule affect an indirect 401(k) rollover?

When an eligible workplace-plan distribution is paid directly to you, the payer generally withholds 20% of the taxable amount for federal income tax. To roll over the full balance, you’d generally need to replace that withheld amount using other funds within the 60-day deadline. The withholding is later credited against your federal tax liability.

What 401(k) rollover fees should I check?

Review both one-time and ongoing costs. These can include investment fees, plan administration expenses, conversion or account opening charges and termination fees. Compare the disclosures for your existing plan and the account you’re considering so you understand how the costs differ.

What problems can come up when rolling a 401(k) into a new employer plan?

Not every employer plan accepts incoming rollovers. Those that do may limit the types of assets they can receive. Before starting the transfer, confirm the receiving plan’s rules and check how your old plan will handle the balance if you leave it there.

Can rolling employer stock into an IRA affect Net Unrealized Appreciation?

Yes, if your 401(k) holds employer stock, rolling those shares into an IRA can affect whether Net Unrealized Appreciation (NUA) tax treatment remains available. The rules depend on how the employer shares are distributed, so consider speaking with a qualified tax professional before moving company stock from a 401(k).




This is informational content sponsored by Crypto.com and should not be considered as investment advice.

Foris Capital US LLC (“FCUL” or referred to herein as “Crypto.com Stocks”) is a broker-dealer registered with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and a Member of the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) and the Securities Investor Protection Corporation (SIPC). For further information about FCUL, please visit FINRA BrokerCheck.  

FCUL is a subsidiary of Crypto.com. FCUL is a separate entity from Crypto.com, Foris DAX, Inc., and other affiliated Foris companies. FCUL does not engage in the sale, transfer or custody of crypto currencies or digital assets. Crypto.com is a separate entity from FCUL and does not engage in the securities business. Customer balances and crypto holdings held and transacted at Crypto.com and other entities outside of FCUL are not covered by SIPC insurance and are separate from securities transactions and holdings at FCUL. Fractional shares are not available for all equities.

All investments involve risk, and not all risks are suitable for every investor. The value of securities may fluctuate and as a result, clients may lose more than their original investment. The past performance of a security, or financial product does not guarantee future results or returns. Keep in mind that while diversification may help spread risk, it does not assure a profit or protect against loss in a down market. There is always the potential of losing money when you invest in securities or other financial products. Investors should consider their investment objectives and risks carefully before investing.

Latest crypto prices